Gainesville, FL Pizza Delivery - I Love NY Pizza

    review rating 5  I've ordered and picked up or had delivered a few of their delicious baked pizzas. But lately, I've taken to ordering their "take and bake" pizzas that you cook in your own oven at home. They are fantastic and you et them fresh and hot out of your own oven.

    thumb Gabino Cuevas
    3/14/2021

    review rating 5  Always good, staff is always friendly. Best pizza in Gainesville!

    thumb Skye Graves
    7/15/2019

    review rating 5  Authentic northeast pizza. Great thin crust, had to get it two days in a row

    thumb Nathan Dzikowski
    8/21/2020

    review rating 4  I went to I love NY Pizza today and got two pepperoni rolls togo. I was a little confused on what I wanted to order and the man working before the counter was very professional and was quick to help me decide what to order for a quick snack. By the time I got home they we still warm. They were a great quick snack and were super affordable. Overall great experience. I give four stars as the selection for smaller snacks was very little.

    thumb Reid Buchanan
    2/09/2021
ORDER ONLINE
CATERING MENU

  • 3 Slider Burgers with Fries
    $9.45
  • Placeholder

    French Fries
    $3.68

  • Garlic Knots 1 pc
    $0.79
  • Placeholder

    Mozzarella Sticks 10 pcs
    $6.83
  • Placeholder

    Pepperoni Roll 1 pc
    $1.31
  • Placeholder

    Rio Rancho

    Bacon, tomatoes & ranch dressing
    $9.50
  • Placeholder

    Margharita

    Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, garlic, mozzarella & basil
    $10.50

  • Meat Lovers Pizza

    Pepperoni, ham, bacon & mozzarella
    $10.50
  • Placeholder

    Deluxe Pizza

    Green peppers, onions, black olives, ham, sausage, mushrooms, meatballs, & pepperoni
    $10.50

  • Original NY Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza
    $8.40

  • Wall Street Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions
    $10.50

Pizza in Gainesville, FL

32608

$10 Minimum
For Deliveries

No Minimum
For Pickup

  • review rating 5  Always good, staff is always friendly. Best pizza in Gainesville!

    thumb Skye Graves
    7/15/2019

    review rating 5  Very friendly staff, pizzas were really fresh and the dough wasn’t heavy at all which I really like.

    thumb Hana cookery
    2/21/2020

    review rating 5  I love NY Pizza has some great pizza and garlic knots, I would rate this as one of the better places to eat pizza in Gainesville. It has a very great atmosphere and dining experience. You get your food in a timely manor and with a friendly staff your guaranteed your Order is right. They also have a wide variety of menu items to choose from besides just pizza, they have calzone’s and sandwiches too.

    thumb Eric Borkowski
    1/13/2020

    review rating 4  They have a chicken parm pizza which is really good and you don't see that many places. All of the pizzas that I have tried are great. The garlic knots are a must. I haven't had many of their dinners but their shrimp scampi was really good but unfortunately no longer on the menu

    thumb Michael Siblik
    5/21/2019

  • review rating 5  Always good, staff is always friendly. Best pizza in Gainesville!

    thumb Skye Graves
    6/26/2019

    review rating 5  Coming from Philly area to live in Gainesville and have been SEARCHING for good pizza

    thumb Celeste Hankinson
    7/23/2020