Gainesville, FL Pizza Delivery - I Love NY Pizza

    review rating 4  Love their pizza!!!!!! Only thing that would make it better for me personally is if they offered vegan cheese♡♡ edit: would you consider getting it? Publix sells it! Id love to work that out with you ♡

    thumb Allison Marek
    9/24/2020

    review rating 5  Very friendly staff, pizzas were really fresh and the dough wasn’t heavy at all which I really like.

    thumb Hana cookery
    2/21/2020

    review rating 5  Been getting food from I Love NY pizza for years, food is consistently yummy and the staff has always been professional and friendly. Just realized yesterday we can now order and pay online 👍😊.

    thumb Banning Collins
    10/08/2020

    review rating 5  A great local pizza joint. If your wanting authentic New York style pizza, here's the place

    thumb Fred Long
    10/28/2020
ORDER ONLINE
CATERING MENU
  • 3 Slider Burgers with Fries

    3 Slider Burgers with Fries
    $9.45
  • French Fries

    French Fries
    $3.68
  • Garlic Knots 1 pc

    Garlic Knots 1 pc
    $0.79
  • Mozzarella Sticks 10 pcs

    Mozzarella Sticks 10 pcs
    $6.83
  • Pepperoni Roll 1 pc

    Pepperoni Roll 1 pc
    $1.31
  • Bacon, tomatoes & ranch dressing

    Rio Rancho

    Bacon, tomatoes & ranch dressing
    $9.50
  • Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, garlic, mozzarella & basil

    Margharita

    Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, garlic, mozzarella & basil
    $10.50
  • Pepperoni, ham, bacon & mozzarella

    Meat Lovers Pizza

    Pepperoni, ham, bacon & mozzarella
    $10.50
  • Green peppers, onions, black olives, ham, sausage, mushrooms, meatballs, & pepperoni

    Deluxe Pizza

    Green peppers, onions, black olives, ham, sausage, mushrooms, meatballs, & pepperoni
    $10.50
  • Placeholder

    Original NY Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza
    $8.40
  • Placeholder

    Wall Street Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions
    $10.50

Pizza in Gainesville, FL

32608

$10 Minimum
For Deliveries

No Minimum
For Pickup

  • review rating 5  Always good, staff is always friendly. Best pizza in Gainesville!

    thumb Skye Graves
    7/15/2019

    review rating 5  Very friendly staff, pizzas were really fresh and the dough wasn’t heavy at all which I really like.

    thumb Hana cookery
    2/21/2020

    review rating 5  I love NY Pizza has some great pizza and garlic knots, I would rate this as one of the better places to eat pizza in Gainesville. It has a very great atmosphere and dining experience. You get your food in a timely manor and with a friendly staff your guaranteed your Order is right. They also have a wide variety of menu items to choose from besides just pizza, they have calzone’s and sandwiches too.

    thumb Eric Borkowski
    1/13/2020

    review rating 4  They have a chicken parm pizza which is really good and you don't see that many places. All of the pizzas that I have tried are great. The garlic knots are a must. I haven't had many of their dinners but their shrimp scampi was really good but unfortunately no longer on the menu

    thumb Michael Siblik
    5/21/2019

  • review rating 5  Always good, staff is always friendly. Best pizza in Gainesville!

    thumb Skye Graves
    6/26/2019

    review rating 5  Coming from Philly area to live in Gainesville and have been SEARCHING for good pizza

    thumb Celeste Hankinson
    7/23/2020