Delivery Area

Pizza in Gainesville, FL

32608

$10 Minimum
For Deliveries

No Minimum
For Pickup

Tara Massini
Tara Massini
08/09/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Delicious and hot pizza and calzones!

Only one critique and suggestion: for online take-out ordering, the estimated time was way off but confusing ("within 60 minutes") and the "your food is ready" message came after the hour had passed rather than when it was actually ready. If there's any way to have actual updates from staff when ready, or putting in the oven, that would be great.

Lisa Marino
Lisa Marino
06/14/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
One of the best pizza's in North Florida. The pizza guy is very talented from crust to sauce to all textures.

patricia eplee
patricia eplee
04/25/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Best Cauliflower Crust Pizza you will ever eat! My favorite is the Roma! They cook it perfectly how like it every time and and the staff is very friendly! I like mine well done because I like my crust crunchy!!

Jonathan Hamilton Jr
Jonathan Hamilton Jr
03/26/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
The pizza was pretty good. I will definitely try again and not to mention, the staff was warm and welcoming. I'm from New York and though I visit, they have lots of great pizzerias around New York City and there are quite a bit similar to I Love NY Pizza and I really enjoy both theirs and the one here.

Gregory Hicks
Gregory Hicks
03/26/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I ordered online, which was user friendly, and my to go order was ready sooner than promised. The Meat Lasagna and Chicken Picatta dinners were excellent and easily made two meals each. The staff was friendly and helpful, and my experience was excellent.

Marissa Tsounakis
Marissa Tsounakis
03/24/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I moved to Florida from Jersey about a year ago. I've gone to so many pizza places here in FL and none of them know how to make pizza. This is the only place that knows how to make it taste similar to Jersey and NY. The pizza was amazing! I highly recommend☺️

Shelly Pitts
Shelly Pitts
02/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Absolutely fantastic pizza! The staff is friendly and upbeat 🙂 I have ordered pizza twice this week! This is definitely my new favorite pizza place!

Jose Castillo
Jose Castillo
02/09/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
We really love I Love NY Pizza! The menue is very large and you could find something for everyone. Love the service and the employees are always friendly. Highly recommended.

Emily Tomlin
Emily Tomlin
01/20/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Fantastic pizza! Their margherita and Roma pizzas especially are superb. Also have great customer service, always polite and efficient on the phone, and courteous delivery drivers too. Best pizza in town, and worth every penny!

Terry Juliano
Terry Juliano
01/10/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Pizza was ready as promised. Really tasty and great thin crust. Pretty close to what you can get in NY.

Puertorican Power (MARIA)
Puertorican Power (MARIA)
12/31/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Always good. Even the take and bake. Is like is coming out of their oven as long as you follow the instructions.

Alex Velasquez
Alex Velasquez
12/26/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I used to live in New York and the pizza there definitely has a distinct taste and texture. I ❤️ NY pizza and Italian gator are the two places in town that come the closest to that classic New York taste. The reason why I prefer I ❤️ NY pizza is because you can actually go inside to order, eat in the patio, and there's parking. Not to bad mouth Italian gator I think they're great too but my bar going days are over I don't feel like competing with drunk college kids for a NY slice. So if I had to point you to a place for great NY style pizza, I'd send you to I ❤️ NY pizza

Alex
Alex
12/26/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I used to live in New York and the pizza there definitely has a distinct taste and texture. I ❤️ NY pizza and Italian gator are the two places in town that come the closest to that classic New York taste. The reason why I prefer I ❤️ NY pizza is because you can actually go inside to order, eat in the patio, and there's parking. Not to bad mouth Italian gator I think they're great too but my bar going days are over I don't feel like competing with drunk college kids for a NY slice. So if I had to point you to a place for great NY style pizza, I'd send you to I ❤️ NY pizza

Denise Adair
Denise Adair
12/21/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
Hawaiian Pizza was great great. Fast friendly service. Great neighbors to have.

Tricia Ayoub
Tricia Ayoub
12/15/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I love I love NY Pizza! I’m actually very partial to the pasta dishes they have. If you haven’t tried them you should try their chicken Francesca! So good!

Corporate Communication
Corporate Communication
10/23/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This gourmet salad was a Joy. Thank you!
This place is a little gem. It has something for everyone, from the delicious pizza and kids menu to the gluten free options and gourmet salads.
Very nice atmosphere and friendly staff.✅
I will come back and will recommend 💚

Angela Wraight
Angela Wraight
10/12/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I have not had pizza this good in years! I’m from RI, home to federal hill & this pizza is better than any pizza I’ve ever had in the most italian capital of the east coast. Also, they don’t close at 8, they close at 9 pm, Monday through Saturday. I’ll definitely be coming back here.

Mary Jo Taber
Mary Jo Taber
09/23/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Excellent crust - all around high quality ingredients. All the employees are very helpful and have good customer service.

Dianne Harris
Dianne Harris
09/22/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
WE LOVE NY PIZZA!!! Consistently delicious since we moved here in 2017 - they are our go to for pizza. Our last order on 9.10.21 of three extra large pizzas for our house party of 20 was perfect!!! Delicious pizza with a chewy crust - Everyone RAVED over the pizzas. Their salads are also outstanding - the spring salad is my favorite!
Hats off to the owners and staff who are AWESOME!!! Thank you!

jeff
jeff
09/16/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Best Pizza in Gainesville! And I'm actually from NY. GREAT group of customer service personell as well

Utopia569
Utopia569
09/11/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This place has a great variety of pizzas and you can buy by the slice. The place has good desserts too

Leah Currier
Leah Currier
09/05/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
my online order got lost and had to wait a while for pizza. That said the pizza was good and a large fed 3 adults
I went back and everything was fine. Good pizza.

Kyle Peppler
Kyle Peppler
08/19/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Ordered delivery. It was a little slow (42 minutes to get here), but it was really good! I got a variation of a large meat lovers with ricotta.

Cindy Turner
Cindy Turner
08/04/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
We moved to the area and are thrilled to have found this awesome pizza restaurant right down the street! We have ordered multiple times and the food is always fresh and delicious. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. We will be regular customers for sure!

Brian Ford
Brian Ford
07/04/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Great food. Great staff. Our family loves their pizza, salads, & garlic knots. Easy online ordering is a plus.

RoadZombie07
RoadZombie07
06/13/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Best white pizza I’ve tried! It was a real nyc style pizza. They had some good desserts 😳

Lisa Gustin
Lisa Gustin
04/29/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I see these places all the time...masking as very poor NY style pizza. It's very annoying and frustrating as an Italian Ny'er. I was pleasantly surprised when the pizza was spot on! Thank you I love NY pizza and now I don't feel so far from home.

Gabino Cuevas
Gabino Cuevas
03/14/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I've ordered and picked up or had delivered a few of their delicious baked pizzas. But lately, I've taken to ordering their "take and bake" pizzas that you cook in your own oven at home. They are fantastic and you et them fresh and hot out of your own oven.

betty smith
betty smith
02/27/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
the food was great as usual. They were very busy, so it took awhile but they gave me a bonus desert for my wait. Not necessary but very appreciated.

Staci McDonough
Staci McDonough
02/19/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
We LOVE I Love NY Pizza. They have the BEST gluten free pizza in town! Food is always great and the delivery is fast.

Randall Moore
Randall Moore
02/12/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
Friendly folks doing their best through the covid era. Selection and options were plentiful. Seating was reduced but available and adequate. Food was delicious and will definitely will return.

Reid Buchanan
Reid Buchanan
02/09/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
I went to I love NY Pizza today and got two pepperoni rolls togo. I was a little confused on what I wanted to order and the man working before the counter was very professional and was quick to help me decide what to order for a quick snack. By the time I got home they we still warm. They were a great quick snack and were super affordable. Overall great experience. I give four stars as the selection for smaller snacks was very little.

Jacob Combs
Jacob Combs
01/22/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Great pizza!!! Very large serving size too so got to have leftovers. Pizza cheese and sauce were super yummy as were the veggies and pepperoni! Pepperoni rolls were also super delicious! Place has a great patio to sit at too. Oh and the Oreo cheesecake is the perfect dessert here!

Amy Solinsky
Amy Solinsky
11/01/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Delicious and unique pizza combinations! Was a hit for a Halloween party! Lots of compliments on it.

Fred Long
Fred Long
10/28/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
A great local pizza joint. If your wanting authentic New York style pizza, here's the place

Banning Collins
Banning Collins
10/08/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Been getting food from I Love NY pizza for years, food is consistently yummy and the staff has always been professional and friendly. Just realized yesterday we can now order and pay online 👍😊.

Stephanie
Stephanie
09/25/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Food is ALWAYS spectacular, order is always correct, and staff is always polite. The only complaint I have is the large delivery fee. I’d rather just tip the driver well then give the restaurant more money for food I’ve already paid for once, and while *I* will still always tip the driver, I’m sure many people are less likely to
Tip drivers well when they have to pay large delivery fees.

Allison Marek
Allison Marek
09/24/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
Love their pizza!!!!!! Only thing that would make it better for me personally is if they offered vegan cheese♡♡ edit: would you consider getting it? Publix sells it! Id love to work that out with you ♡

Sofaking738
Sofaking738
09/19/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Very good Pizza. Prompt deliver and extremely courteous delivery man!!! Thank you all very much!!

Allison Marek
Allison Marek
09/13/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
Love their pizza!!!!!! Only thing that would make it better for me personally is if they offered vegan cheese♡♡

sadaf jeelani
sadaf jeelani
09/06/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Pizza was yummy. Salad was awesome! Delivery was quick.

AJ Wilson
AJ Wilson
09/05/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
My order was not done at the time specified in my online order, but the pizza was great. Maybe a little light on the toppings and it seemed as if they were just dropped in a clump and not spread out. I had to rearrange the toppings to make sure there was some on all the slices.

Francisco Félix
Francisco Félix
08/26/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Man! I literally Love NY Pizza! It’s really good. You gotta try their salads, too.

Nathan Dzikowski
Nathan Dzikowski
08/21/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Authentic northeast pizza. Great thin crust, had to get it two days in a row

Celeste Hankinson
Celeste Hankinson
07/23/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Coming from Philly area to live in Gainesville and have been SEARCHING for good pizza

Hana cookery
Hana cookery
02/21/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Very friendly staff, pizzas were really fresh and the dough wasn’t heavy at all which I really like.

Hana cookery
Hana cookery
02/21/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Very friendly staff, pizzas were really fresh and the dough wasn’t heavy at all which I really like.

Eric Borkowski
Eric Borkowski
01/13/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I love NY Pizza has some great pizza and garlic knots, I would rate this as one of the better places to eat pizza in Gainesville. It has a very great atmosphere and dining experience. You get your food in a timely manor and with a friendly staff your guaranteed your Order is right. They also have a wide variety of menu items to choose from besides just pizza, they have calzone’s and sandwiches too.

Skye Graves
Skye Graves
07/15/2019

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Always good, staff is always friendly. Best pizza in Gainesville!

Skye Graves
Skye Graves
06/26/2019

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Always good, staff is always friendly. Best pizza in Gainesville!

Michael Siblik
Michael Siblik
05/21/2019

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
They have a chicken parm pizza which is really good and you don't see that many places. All of the pizzas that I have tried are great. The garlic knots are a must. I haven't had many of their dinners but their shrimp scampi was really good but unfortunately no longer on the menu